Notes from experience in tanneries, cutting rooms, and factories.
This is a collection of experiences from being in this trade—working with global tanneries, working with factories, and advising buyers who have to make margins work— We can tell you one thing plainly: leather grading causes more confusion than almost anything else we sell. Not because it’s complicated, but because it’s often explained poorly.
Let’s clear something up immediately. Grading has nothing to do with how well the leather is tanned. A Grade 1 hide and a Grade 3 hide from the same article went through the same drums, the same recipes, and the same finishing lines. The difference is simply how much of that hide you can cut cleanly without working around defects.
Once you understand that, bulk buying starts to make a lot more sense.
How Grading Actually Happens at the Tannery
Grading is done at the very end of production, during pack-out. Every hide is laid out, inspected by eye, and assigned a grade based on usable surface area. That’s it. No machines. No tensile tests. Just experience and percentages.
Each hide is graded individually. There is no averaging across a shipment. When a buyer orders a certain grade, the tannery selects hides that meet that yield requirement and builds a pack.
And this is where many buyers get tripped up: grading is about yield, not beauty. A hide can have character and still be high grade. Another can be technically sound but full of cosmetic interruptions and end up lower grade.
Pairing: The Part No One Explains Well Enough
Pairing is where grading really starts to matter in production. If you’re making products that need symmetry—left and right panels, matched sides of a bag, large desk pads—pairing will make or break your efficiency.
Higher grades are easier to pair. The grain is more consistent, the wrinkles are predictable, and the clean areas line up from hide to hide. As grades drop, pairing becomes harder. The color may match, but the grain won’t. One hide cuts clean, the next fights you.
If you’ve ever had two hides from the same batch that “should” match but don’t, you’ve seen this firsthand.
What the Grades Really Mean in Practice
Grade 1 / A – Premium Selection
Usable yield: roughly 85–90%
Pairing: straightforward and reliable
You’ll still see marks—this is real leather—but they’re small and usually pushed to the edges.
Typical issues:
-
Small healed scars
-
Minor edge defects
-
Light neck character
This grade is chosen when cutting efficiency matters more than price: luxury goods, large panels, anything where you don’t want to fight the hide.
Grade 2 – Standard Selection
Usable yield: roughly 75–85%
Pairing: very workable
This is where most professional buyers live. You get honest leather with manageable character.
Common defects:
-
Light scratches
-
Neck wrinkles
-
Vein marks
-
Slight looseness in the belly
If you know how to cut, Grade 2 gives you the best return for your money. Most factories and serious workshops should start here.
Grade 3 – Commercial Selection
Usable yield: roughly 65–75%
Pairing: possible, but selective
Now you’re working around the hide instead of with it.
Typical defects:
-
Larger scars
-
Insect bites
-
Brand marks
-
Veins through visible areas
-
Loose grain in neck and belly
Grade 3 is not bad leather—but it demands planning. If your products use smaller parts or mixed components, you can extract real value. If you need large clean panels, this grade will slow you down.
Grade 4–5 – Utility Grades
Usable yield: under 65%
Pairing: unreliable
These hides are sold cheap for a reason.
Expect:
-
Multiple heavy scars
-
Strong wrinkles
-
Uneven grain across the hide
-
Structural stretch in problem areas
They have their place, but that place is not precision work.
What a Standard Mixed-Grade Pack Really Is
A standard mixed-grade pack is a deliberate compromise between yield and price, and it’s one of the most common ways factories buy leather. A typical breakdown might look like 20% Grade A, 40% Grade B, and 40% Grade C, though the exact percentages vary by tannery and article.
This is not the same as Tannery Run. Mixed-grade packs are intentionally built to a formula. The tannery still sorts the hides, but instead of delivering a single grade, they assemble a balanced pack that reflects normal production reality while keeping the average cost down.
In practice, this works well for factories running multiple SKUs or component sizes. Grade A hides are reserved for the most visible parts, Grade B handles the bulk of production, and Grade C is used for smaller pieces, internal panels, or parts that will be lined or reinforced. For buyers who understand their cutting flow, mixed-grade packs can be one of the most economical ways to buy leather without introducing too much variability.
What “Tannery Run” Actually Means
A Tannery Run (TR) pack means the buyer takes the hides as they come off the line, across the natural grade spread of the article. No sorting. No cherry-picking.
You’ll usually see mostly Grade 2 and 3, a few nice hides, and a few that keep you honest.
TR is not for beginners. It’s for buyers who understand cutting layouts, can assign clean areas to visible parts, and don’t panic when every hide isn’t perfect. Used properly, TR can lower your material cost significantly. Used poorly, it creates waste.
How Experienced Buyers Maximize Value
The biggest mistake we see is buyers chasing the lowest price per square foot. That’s the wrong number to focus on. You can’t get what you didn’t pay for. What actually matters (or should matter) is cost per usable square foot.
Sometimes paying more for a higher grade saves money:
-
Less waste
-
Faster cutting
-
Easier pairing
-
Fewer rejected parts
After enough years in this business, you stop asking “What’s the cheapest leather?” and start asking “What cuts cleanly and keeps production moving?”
That’s the difference between “buying leather” and “buying yield”. What is more important to you? And how much will you pay for quality (and, as a result, your reputation for great products) is the key question. So make smart decisions, and come here to shop for great leathers. We spend a lot of time thinking about these matters for you, our smart customers, so you can focus on your designs and selling your master creations.
One last thing we would add is, there are many tanneries that are still on their journey towards certification by Working Standards bodies for their manufacturing practices for environmental stewardship. Some are still making capital improvements to their tanneries in their journey to become fully green. After all, it takes a lot of capital investment for such efforts. So some of them can still afford to keep costs low (when compared to fully certified ones) and price their leathers extremely competitively to profit from volume sales. So beware of unintended environmental effects of buying “cheap” leather. There are good deals to be had occasionally, but make smart choices when shop. Because how you buy can collectively change this world, since your actions have consequences (both intended and unintended). Choose your leather buying strategy wisely.